As 2025 draws to a close, one question looms large in the world of football: Who truly deserves the title of the best men's player this year? With a mix of seasoned veterans and rising stars dominating the pitch, this year has been nothing short of spectacular. But here's where it gets controversial—while some names are obvious, others might just surprise you. BBC Sport dives into the standout performances of the year, and we want you to decide who takes the crown. Cast your vote at the end of this article, but first, let’s explore the contenders who’ve made 2025 unforgettable.
Harry Kane (Bayern Munich)
The England captain has been nothing short of phenomenal this year, proving age is just a number. At 32, Kane has netted an astonishing 60 goals for both club and country, though he’s still chasing Lionel Messi’s record of 91 goals in 2012. But here’s the kicker: Does consistency over a decade make Kane a stronger contender than a single record-breaking year? Let’s debate that in the comments.
Lamine Yamal (Barcelona)
At just 18, Yamal has already become a household name, dazzling fans with his performances for Spain during their Euro 2024 victory and continuing his rise in 2025. With seven goals and eight assists in just 14 La Liga games this season, he’s a talent to watch. But is youth enough to outshine experience? You tell us.
Ousmane Dembele (Paris St-Germain)
Dembele’s 2025 started with a bang—15 goals in his first eight games, culminating in a career-best 35 goals in 53 games. His Ballon d’Or win speaks volumes, but his form has dipped slightly this term. Does one incredible season outweigh a minor slump? Weigh in below.
Erling Haaland (Man City)
Haaland’s goal-scoring prowess is undeniable. With 25 goals in 24 appearances for Manchester City and 16 goals in Norway’s World Cup qualifiers, he’s a force of nature. But here’s the twist: Is he too reliant on his team’s setup, or is he the ultimate game-changer? Share your thoughts.
Cole Palmer (Chelsea)
Despite injury setbacks, Palmer shone at the Club World Cup, outperforming global stars with three goals and two assists. At 23, he’s already a key player for Chelsea, but does potential outweigh current impact? Let’s discuss.
Nuno Mendes (Paris St-Germain)
In a team that won the Treble, Nuno Mendes stands out as one of the world’s best left-backs. His defensive solidity and attacking contributions are unmatched, but does a defender’s role get enough credit in these conversations? Your opinions matter.
Gianluigi Donnarumma (Man City)
Named FIFA’s best goalkeeper for 2025, Donnarumma’s move from PSG to Manchester City has been seamless. Winning the Champions League and three domestic trophies with PSG, he’s now a cornerstone of Pep Guardiola’s side. But is goalkeeping undervalued in the player of the year debate? Let us know.
Pedri (Barcelona)
At 23, Pedri has cemented his place as one of the world’s best midfielders, helping Barcelona win the domestic treble in 2024-25. With 254 recoveries and 70 chances created last season, he’s a midfield maestro. But does his injury history affect his case? We want to hear from you.
Kylian Mbappe (Real Madrid)
Mbappe’s 59 goals in 2025 have matched Cristiano Ronaldo’s 2013 record, solidifying his status as a goal machine. But here’s the question: Is equalling a record as impressive as breaking one? Join the debate.
Vitinha (Paris St-Germain)
Defensive midfielders rarely get the spotlight, but Vitinha’s 2025 has been exceptional. Compared to Andres Iniesta, his technique and positioning have made him a midfield anchor for PSG. But does his role limit his recognition? Share your perspective.
And this is the part most people miss—while goals and assists steal the show, it’s the balance of individual brilliance and team impact that truly defines a player’s greatness. So, who’s your pick for the best men’s player of 2025? Vote now and let’s settle this once and for all!
